The control theory of switching power supplies can be quite abstract and challenging to grasp. System instability is a common issue, and many engineers struggle with understanding how to adjust it or why certain systems become unstable during mass production. There are plenty of technical resources that dive deep into the mathematical theories behind control systems, but they often feel overwhelming. So, how can we truly understand the loop stability in a switching power supply?
Cedar once shared a metaphor that I found very insightful, and I’d like to share it with you:
Imagine the feedback loop as a wife giving her husband a back massage. At first, she asks, “Did you eat? You don’t have any strength.†She starts working harder, adding more pressure each time. Her husband responds, “You’re doing too much, you’ll kill me!†This cycle continues, and it’s a perfect example of loop instability.
I recently came across another metaphor that uses the relationship between a man and a woman to explain poles and zeros in control systems. Let’s start with the pole. A simple example is an RC filter. It acts as an open circuit for DC (capacitor C blocks DC) and a short circuit at high frequencies (capacitor C allows AC). On a Bode plot, the amplitude is flat before the pole and then decreases by -20 dB/dec after the pole. Think of this as a man—initially full of energy, but over time, he may lose his spark, just like men often do in relationships.
On the other hand, a zero is like a woman. Take the ESR zero of a capacitor, for example. At DC, the capacitor has infinite resistance, but as frequency increases, its resistance decreases. After the pole, the ESR resistor no longer reduces in value. So, a man is like fire—passionate and intense, while a woman is like water—calm and enduring. Women tend to last longer in love, and their impact is subtle but lasting. This analogy helps explain the difference between poles and zeros in a system.
Now, let's talk about two men. Unfortunately, I’ve been living near San Francisco for a long time, so I won't go into details about "comrades." But when you have an LC filter, it creates a double pole. Two men often clash, just like a high Q factor. An LC circuit with no parasitic resistance has an infinitely high Q, which amplifies signals at the resonant frequency. That’s why tuning a radio involves adjusting a small capacitor to receive different stations. The conflict between the two men leads to instability, and the level of conflict depends on the damping (or parasitic resistance). A high Q system can cause rapid phase shifts, making it hard to stabilize.
To compensate for instability, we usually add a zero. However, this also introduces a high-frequency pole. For example, adding a capacitor to the feedback node creates a zero-pole pair. Understanding this is like understanding a love story. The zero comes first, just like a woman entering a relationship early on. Men are often most interested in the beginning, similar to how a man might take a woman shopping. Once the relationship deepens, the truth comes out, and if the love happens before the "pole" (the point where things get serious), it could end in tragedy. If it happens after, it becomes a lasting love.
In control systems, a pole reduces the amplitude (good for stability) but also reduces the phase margin (bad for stability). A zero does the opposite—it increases the amplitude (bad for stability) but improves the phase margin (good for stability). Both contribute to system behavior, but a right-half-plane zero is particularly problematic, as it worsens both amplitude and phase margin, like a witch in a love story.
For example, in a boost converter, when the switch is on, the inductor stores energy; when the diode is on, it delivers that energy to the load. The output current is roughly IL(1-D). As the duty cycle D increases, the output current actually decreases, which is why a boost converter behaves like a "witch"—it has a negative sign in its transfer function, making it inherently unstable without proper compensation.
Negative feedback systems work by reducing output when it's too high, but the loop itself introduces phase lag. If the phase shift reaches 180°, the negative feedback turns into positive feedback, leading to oscillation. The key to stability is ensuring that when the loop gain is 1 (0 dB), the phase lag is less than 180°, ideally under 135° for a safety margin.
Take a current-mode buck converter as an example. The inductor current is limited, so the inductance loses its influence. The main circuit consists of one pole from Rload and Cout (a man) and the ESR zero of the output capacitor (a woman). The control part adds another low-frequency pole (another man). With two men and one woman, the system can be unstable. The position of the ESR zero determines whether compensation is needed. Electrolytic capacitors have low-zero frequencies, so they may not require compensation, while ceramic capacitors have high-zero frequencies and often need additional zeros for stability.
Voltage-mode buck converters are even trickier, as they have multiple poles from L and Cout, plus the control pole. This means three "men" in the system, making it harder to stabilize. Like a teenager going through many relationships, voltage-mode converters may need several compensations to mature and become stable.
Finally, how are the poles and zeros in a switching circuit derived? It’s not complicated. When a switching power supply operates, it alternates between different states, each governed by a different state equation. To model the overall system, we use a weighted average of these states, similar to describing a path as a combination of steps in different directions. Adding small-signal perturbations and solving the equations gives us the poles and zeros of the system.
Understanding this process helps clarify how complex switching circuits behave and how to design them for stability. Whether you're dealing with a simple buck converter or a more advanced topology, the principles remain the same: balance poles and zeros, manage phase margins, and ensure the system doesn’t fall into instability.
·Small size, low weight, easy to operating, installation and maintenance.
·World most famous brand diesel engine: Mitsubishi Engine
·World famous brand AC alternator: Stamford, MeccAlte, Leroy Somer, etc
·Advanced and reliable controller: Auto Start AMF & Remote control by PC with RS232/485
·Full range protect function and alarm shutdown feature.
Mitsubishi Diesel Generators :
·Engine and alternator shall be mounted on a same frame steel skid.
·Built-in damper for anti-vibration.·Small size, low weight, easy to operating, installation and maintenance.
·World most famous brand diesel engine: Mitsubishi Engine
·World famous brand AC alternator: Stamford, MeccAlte, Leroy Somer, etc
·Advanced and reliable controller: Auto Start AMF & Remote control by PC with RS232/485
·Full range protect function and alarm shutdown feature.
·Comply with ISO8528 national standard and ISO9001 quality standard.
Mitsubishi Diesel generator,Mitsubishi diesel genset,Mitsubishi genset,Mitsubishi generator,Mitsubishi diesel engine
Guangdong Superwatt Power Equipment Co., Ltd , https://www.swtgenset.com