**I. Preface: The Smart Speaker Market Is in a Storm of Competition**
In November 2014, Amazon launched the Echo, a small device that quickly sparked a revolution in the smart speaker market. No one could have predicted how fast it would become a household name.
On the global stage, tech giants like Microsoft, Google, and Apple also entered the arena, launching their own intelligent speakers with strong ambitions to dominate the market. Meanwhile, on the domestic front, companies such as Jingdong, Xunfei, BAT (Baidu, Alibaba, Tencent), Xiaomi, Lenovo, Rokid, Himalayan, and many others joined the race. It was clear from the start that the smart speaker market had become a hot trend.
The gameplay for smart speakers has been relatively consistent since the launch of the first Echo: a traditional speaker combined with an AI voice assistant, internet services, and multi-device control. Behind this standard setup lies a fierce competition over resources and ecosystems. From AI chips to distribution channels, a new industrial chain is emerging, and a battle for the living room has quietly begun.
This time, we're comparing two popular domestic smart speakers: the Xiaomi AI Speaker, developed by Xiaomi's TV team, Brain team, and Exploration Lab, and the Tmall Genie X1, created by Alibaba AI Labs.
Both devices have captured widespread consumer attention due to their high cost-performance ratio. Today, we'll put them to the test and let the facts decide which one truly deserves a place in your living room.
**II. Appearance Comparison: Sleek Black and White Designs with Unique Features**
1. **Front Design Comparison**
The Xiaomi AI Speaker features a square design with a clean white finish. Its front panel has dot matrix sound holes and a Xiaomi logo, resembling a smaller version of a Xiaomi air purifier—simple yet tech-savvy.
The Tmall Genie X1, on the other hand, comes in black with a segmented cylindrical design. It has a subtle dot-matrix logo in the center, giving it a low-key, sophisticated look thanks to its matte texture and curved body.
2. **Top Control Interface Comparison**
The Xiaomi AI Speaker’s top panel includes buttons and a light strip. Under normal operation, it emits blue lights, while orange lights appear when waiting for a phone or Bluetooth connection. You can adjust the volume by swiping clockwise or counterclockwise, but the lack of backlighting makes it less convenient in the dark.
The Tmall Genie X1’s top panel is simpler, featuring a mute button and six microphones. Hidden backlight volume controls are located on either side of the mute button.
3. **Bottom Design Comparison**
The Tmall Genie X1 has a ring of RGB breathing lights at the bottom. It turns red when muted and blue when awakened. These lights are soft and non-dazzling even at night due to the way they reflect off the surface.
The Xiaomi AI Speaker’s bottom is more straightforward, featuring a charging port and a non-slip pad.
4. **Summary**
Both devices have distinct appearances. The Xiaomi AI Speaker offers a sleek white design, while the Tmall Genie X1 provides a more compact and elegant black option. The Tmall Genie X1 is slightly smaller and more unobtrusive in the living room.
**III. Function Comparison: Basic Functions Are Fully Developed, Tmall Genie Wins**
1. **Speaker Function**
Both the Xiaomi AI Speaker and the Tmall Genie X1 require connecting to a dedicated app before use. They both support Bluetooth and Wi-Fi control.
**Music Interface Comparison**
The Xiaomi AI Speaker's music interface is more stylish and follows a flat design, whereas the Tmall Genie X1's interface is simpler. The Xiaomi app also asks users about music preferences during initialization, allowing for more personalized song recommendations.
The Tmall Genie X1 benefits from Alibaba's ecosystem, offering access toè™¾ç±³éŸ³ä¹ (Xiami Music) and QQ Music, as well as Himalaya FM. Its resource library is vast and unmatched.
2. **Sound Performance Comparison**
When testing "Hotel California," the Xiaomi AI Speaker delivered clear mid-to-high frequencies and transparent vocals, while the Tmall Genie X1 offered deep bass and rich sound layers, with slightly extended highs.
3. **Summary**
The Xiaomi AI Speaker excels in UI design and mid-to-high frequency performance, while the Tmall Genie X1 shines in bass depth and resource diversity. Both are competitive.
**IV. Intelligent Voice Interaction: Tmall Genie Shows Superiority**
The Xiaomi AI Speaker uses “Little Love Classmate,†while the Tmall Genie X1 uses AliGenie, known for its advanced semantic understanding.
**Wake-Up Experience**
Both wake up quickly within 5 meters, even with whispers or heavy accents. However, the Tmall Genie X1 reminds users with a friendly message after a period of inactivity.
**Conversation Experience**
Both handle simple commands well, with high recognition rates. The Xiaomi AI Speaker is more playful and human-like, while the Tmall Genie X1 focuses on practicality and accuracy.
**Summary**
Both perform well in basic voice recognition, but the Tmall Genie X1 shows better semantic understanding and conversational flow.
**V. Internet Function Expansion: Tmall Genie Has a Clear Edge**
The Xiaomi AI Speaker supports home appliance control via the Mi Home app, but its ecosystem is limited. In contrast, the Tmall Genie X1 supports 6 categories and 38 sub-categories of smart home products through Alibaba’s ecosystem.
It also features voiceprint recognition, enabling personalized settings and secure voice-based payments. Additionally, it supports voice shopping, delivery tracking, and even food delivery orders.
**VI. Conclusion: Tmall Genie X1 Has a Unique Advantage**
While the Xiaomi AI Speaker offers good value and a fun user experience, the Tmall Genie X1 stands out with its extensive ecosystem, third-party integration, and practical functions like voice shopping and delivery tracking.
Backed by Alibaba’s massive resources, the Tmall Genie X1 is currently the most practical and promising smart speaker in the domestic market. With continuous updates and expansion, its potential is nearly limitless.
For those looking for a smart speaker that not only entertains but also simplifies daily life, the Tmall Genie X1 is a strong contender.
Machine Roomless Freight Elevator
Warehouse Elevator,Machine Roomless Freight Elevator,Cargo Goods Lift,Cargo Elevator
ZHONG HAN INTERNATIONAL TRADE CO., LTD , https://www.cck-ht.com